Seaweed

Scotland’s dredging ban protects Summer Isles maerl, and scallops rebound

The Summer Isles maerl beds off Scotland’s northwest coast have survived a decade of protection from scallop dredging, and a local scallop diver says scallops are rebounding alongside them. Maerl is a pink seaweed whose chalky skeletons form beds, and marine biologist Jason Hall-Spencer carbon-dated the beds in the bay at about 9,000 years old. The Guardian reported in September that a marine biologist’s report credits a 2016 dredging ban with protecting them.

At a glance

  • The ban: Scotland made a ban on scallop dredging permanent in 2016 across the Wester Ross Marine Protected Area, which covers about 230 square miles.
  • The habitat: Hall-Spencer’s report for the Blue Hope Alliance says the ban “protected the maerl to a massive extent.”
  • The catch: Illegal dredging and an invasive algae have still damaged some maerl, and fishing rules for many other Scottish inshore protected areas are not yet in place.

Why the Summer Isles maerl matters

Maerl beds act as nurseries for scallops and fish, according to the Guardian. The beds in the bay are about 9,000 years old.

Hall-Spencer warns, citing NatureScot, that a single pass of heavy towed gear can crush or bury up to 70% of the maerl it touches.

How the protection came about

Scotland designated the Wester Ross Marine Protected Area in 2014, with maerl beds and flameshell beds among its protected features, according to the Wester Ross Fisheries Trust. The trust noted that the designation gave no extra legal powers, and that scallop dredging could continue across most of the area.

A 2016 Scottish order re-made the dredge restrictions from a 2015 order on a permanent basis, according to the legislation. The Guardian reports that residents, divers, and creel fishers campaigned for the ban and gave ministers a dossier of evidence.

What divers and fishers report

Scallop diver Alasdair Hughson of the Scottish Creel Fishermen’s Federation says the scallop recovery has been massive. Members of a local rowing club say they see more minke whales, dolphins, and porpoises than 10 years ago. Anglers report a wider variety of fish in their catches, including haddock and cod, and a large herring spawning ground has been spotted nearby.

These sightings are anecdotal, and the Guardian’s account gives no fish counts.

Hand-diving for scallops and creel fishing by local boats under 150 gross tons are still allowed in the area. The Blue Hope Alliance, a coalition of local divers, creel fishers, and community groups, now runs a three-year project with more than £153,000 of support, the Guardian reports.

What is still at risk

The beds are not out of danger. The Guardian reports that illegal dredging and an invasive algae have damaged some maerl. Scientists suspect nutrients from salmon farms may feed the algae.

The wider picture is mixed. Prawn trawling is still permitted in designated parts of the area, according to the Guardian. Scottish Environment LINK says the government missed its original 2016 deadline for setting fishing rules in its protected areas.

The government launched a public consultation on September 14 on fishing rules across more than 160 inshore sites and areas. It runs until January 18, 2027. In June, Environmental Standards Scotland, an independent watchdog, concluded that Scottish ministers have failed in their legal duties to protect and restore the seafloor.

Read more

For more on this story, see: The Guardian (via inkl)

For more from Good News for Humankind, see:

About this article

  • 🤖 This article is AI-generated, based on a framework created by Peter Schulte.
  • 🌍 It aims to be inspirational but clear-eyed, accurate, and evidence-based, and grounded in care for the Earth, peace and belonging for all, and human evolution.
  • 💬 Leave your notes and suggestions in the comments below — I will do my best to review and implement where appropriate.
  • ✉️ One verified piece of good news, one insight from Antihero Project, every weekday morning. Subscribe free.

Coach, writer, and recovering hustle hero. I help purpose-driven humans do good in the world in dark times - without the burnout.