Seeking out evidence

We often imagine that our brains work something like this: 1) we objectively gather data and information from the world around us, 2) we use that data to build rational conclusions about ourselves and the world, and 3) behave according to those rational conclusions.

Instead, how our brains usually work is probably something more like this: 1) we have engrained conclusions or assumptions about ourselves and the world based on what we learned as children, often from traumatic experiences, 2) we actively seek out evidence from the world to confirm those assumptions (and filter out contradicting information), and 3) having inevitably found the evidence we were looking for, behave according to our existing belief system. Rather than objectively observing the world, we often bend, filter, and distort what we observe to confirm what we already (consciously or unconsciously) believe to be true, like “I don’t belong,” “I can’t do it,” “people are idiots,” “people are jerks,” etc.

Some of the most powerful questions in coaching then become:

  • What assumptions or beliefs about myself or the world have I been unconsciously gathering evidence for?
  • What am I not allowing myself to see and experience because of that?
  • What new assumptions and beliefs might better serve me and the world?

Peter Schulte AI-generated headshot

I help aspiring changemakers do good in the world and feel good in the process.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More Great to Good posts


  • Pain is not the enemy

    Pain is not the enemy

    It’s not actually our pain that stands in our way. It’s our wounds that hinder us. It’s our wounds that need to be healed. Our…


  • Big life update

    Big life update

    At the end of last year, Sara and I decided to end our romantic relationship. But we haven't separated in the usual sense. We still…


  • Never be closing

    Never be closing

    In the 1992 film Glengarry Glen Ross, Alec Baldwin's character famously says "Always Be Closing," advocating a relentless, aggressive approach to finalizing business sales. I'm…